A South African Legal Framework to Govern Online Harm: What Might We Learn from the EU’s Digital Services Act?
Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung (KAS), Media Programme Sub-Saharan Africa (2026), viii, 92 pp.
ISBN 978-1-0483-7323-3 (print); 978-1-0483-7324-0 (pdf)
"South Africa does not need its own Digital Services Act. Attempting to reproduce the European framework provision by provision would be neither realistic nor desirable. The DSA reflects the particular legal and institutional architecture of the European Union and is supported by regulatory resources and economic leverage that South Africa does not possess. Its value for South Africa lies instead in the regulatory principles and mechanisms it offers for consideration and adaptation.
Perhaps the most important lesson is that meaningful regulation of digital platforms need not require intermediaries to become generally liable for what their users say, nor the state to assume responsibility for determining what information may appear online. Appropriate protection from liability for third-party content can coexist with direct obligations upon the companies that design and operate digital services. Platforms may remain protected from automatic liability for users’ speech, while being required to maintain accessible complaint procedures, explain consequential decisions, disclose meaningful information about their operations, permit appropriate external scrutiny, assess and mitigate serious risks generated by their systems, protect children using their services and comply with lawful regulatory requirements.
That distinction is particularly important in South Africa. Our constitutional commitment to freedom of expression counsels strongly against regulatory models that incentivise indiscriminate removal of contested speech or confer broad powers upon public authorities to determine what may be said online. But freedom of expression does not require that the private infrastructures through which an ever-greater share of public communication takes place remain opaque, inaccessible or effectively beyond the reach of public law. The analysis in this report therefore points towards a framework in which responsibility is differentiated according to what a service does, the risks it creates and the power it exercises. Regulation must begin by ensuring that providers substantially serving South Africans are within the effective reach of South African law. It should make consequential exercises of platform power more transparent and contestable, provide regulators and independent researchers with the information necessary for meaningful scrutiny, and impose greater responsibilities where the scale or nature of a service creates greater risks. Those responsibilities must also be meaningful in South African conditions, including for children and across the country’s diverse linguistic and social contexts." (Conclusion, page 89)
Perhaps the most important lesson is that meaningful regulation of digital platforms need not require intermediaries to become generally liable for what their users say, nor the state to assume responsibility for determining what information may appear online. Appropriate protection from liability for third-party content can coexist with direct obligations upon the companies that design and operate digital services. Platforms may remain protected from automatic liability for users’ speech, while being required to maintain accessible complaint procedures, explain consequential decisions, disclose meaningful information about their operations, permit appropriate external scrutiny, assess and mitigate serious risks generated by their systems, protect children using their services and comply with lawful regulatory requirements.
That distinction is particularly important in South Africa. Our constitutional commitment to freedom of expression counsels strongly against regulatory models that incentivise indiscriminate removal of contested speech or confer broad powers upon public authorities to determine what may be said online. But freedom of expression does not require that the private infrastructures through which an ever-greater share of public communication takes place remain opaque, inaccessible or effectively beyond the reach of public law. The analysis in this report therefore points towards a framework in which responsibility is differentiated according to what a service does, the risks it creates and the power it exercises. Regulation must begin by ensuring that providers substantially serving South Africans are within the effective reach of South African law. It should make consequential exercises of platform power more transparent and contestable, provide regulators and independent researchers with the information necessary for meaningful scrutiny, and impose greater responsibilities where the scale or nature of a service creates greater risks. Those responsibilities must also be meaningful in South African conditions, including for children and across the country’s diverse linguistic and social contexts." (Conclusion, page 89)
1 Scope and differentiated application: Which digital services should be regulated? 16
2 Intermediary liability and safe harbours: Modernising South Africa’s existing framework, 21
3 Establishing jurisdiction and effective local accountability, 29
4 Accessible complaint, notice and redress mechanisms, 34
5 Transparency and reporting, 45
6 Access to platform data and independent research, 52
7 Systemic risk assessment adapted to South African circumstances, 58
8 Protection of minors online, 65
9 Local linguistic, cultural and contextual capacity, 71
10 Funding effective oversight: A proportionate supervisory fee, 74
11 Institutional architecture and co-regulation, 76
12 Effective enforcement, 83
Conclusion, 89
2 Intermediary liability and safe harbours: Modernising South Africa’s existing framework, 21
3 Establishing jurisdiction and effective local accountability, 29
4 Accessible complaint, notice and redress mechanisms, 34
5 Transparency and reporting, 45
6 Access to platform data and independent research, 52
7 Systemic risk assessment adapted to South African circumstances, 58
8 Protection of minors online, 65
9 Local linguistic, cultural and contextual capacity, 71
10 Funding effective oversight: A proportionate supervisory fee, 74
11 Institutional architecture and co-regulation, 76
12 Effective enforcement, 83
Conclusion, 89