"The organizations that conduct country rankings should continue to increase technical sophistication, cultural neutrality, and transparency. In particular, continued attention must be paid to digital media, notably the Internet and mobile phones, which now number approximately 4.6 billion worldwide. Donors and implementers of media assistance, meanwhile, should keep up efforts to find better ways to monitor and evaluate specific programs and to share the resulting information with other aid organizations. At a time of financial shortfalls, foundations and other funding bodies should assure that assessment of media quality at both the national and the program level receives the attention (and the money) that it deserves." (Executive summary, page 5)
Overview of the Evaluators (Freedom House, IREX, Reporters Without Borders), 6
Taking the Studies to Task, 17
Old Media Versus New Media, 28
Changing with the Times, 30
How Good is the Social Science? 33
Why Have Media Freedom if It Means Bad Media? 36
Whom to Ask? Experts or Citizens? 38
So Just How Good Are These Indexes? 40
Evaluating at the Micro Level, 44
Recommendations, 50
Endnotes, 51
Appendix I: Freedom House’s Freedom of the Press 2010, 56
Appendix II: IREX’s Media Sustainability Index, 59
Appendix III: Reporters Without Borders’ Press Freedom Index 2009, 61