Document details

Patterns in the Chaos: News and Nationalism in Afghanistan, America and Pakistan During Wartime, 2010-2012

New York City: Columbia University, Doctoral Thesis (2013), xxi, 407 pp.

Contains bibliogr. pp. 366-394

"This dissertation examines the United States’s elite news media’s hegemony in a global media landscape, and how it can come to stand for the entire American nation in the imagination of outsiders. In this transnational, instantaneous digital media arena, what is created for an American audience can fairly easily be accessed, interpreted and relayed to another. How, then, is U.S. international news, which is traditionally ethnocentric and security-focused, absorbed in Afghanistan and Pakistan, two countries where the United States has acute foreign policy interests? [...] There is a widespread, long-standing perception in Afghanistan and Pakistan that American journalists stain the reputation of their nations as failed states. Just as the U.S. exercises global hegemony in a material sense, the U.S. media is powerful in shaping how American and international publics see the world. Yet, while American foreign correspondents are U.S.-centric in their reportage on the Afghan, American and Pakistani entanglement, so too are Afghan journalists Afghan-centric and Pakistani journalists Pakistani-centric. Nationalism is how journalists organize chaos and complexity. While their news stories can represent an entire nation, they are more likely to harden national identities than to broker understanding between nations." (Abstract)
PART I: THE BACKGROUND
1 The Afghan, American, Pakistani Entanglement: Introduction, 2
2 Nationalism in America, Nationalism Everywhere: Literature Review, 20
3 Twice the Forgotten War: American News on Afghanistan & Pakistan, 60
PART II: THE PAKISTANIS
4 From Quiet to Chaos: Pakistani News Media, Past and Present, 81
5 'We Realized Our Power': The Pakistani Journalist Experience, 105
6 'So Much America in Pakistan, It's Staggering': Journalists and U.S. News, 123
PART III: THE AFGHANS
7 A Shaky Start: Afghan News Media, Past and Present, 164
8 Optimistic, But Uncertain: The Afghan Journalist Experience, 190
9 'We Can't Do This Alone': Afghan Journalists and U.S. News, 219
PART IV: THE AMERICANS
10 'We Write for Us': The American Journalists' Experience, 250
11 Dysfunction: U.S. Journalists View of Afghan, Pakistani Reporters & Officials, 264
12 Clarity in Chaos: Nationalism to Manage Reportage, 282