Document details

Untold Stories: How Corruption and Conflicts of Interest Stalk the Newsroom

London: Ethical Journalism Network (EJN) (2015), v, 82 pp.
"This report, which has been produced by a group of distinguished journalists and their supporters, examines the broad scope of the crisis. It covers countries where media are on the frontline of tough political battles, such as Egypt and Turkey. In Ukraine, for instance, the practice of paid-for journalism is a tool routinely used by politicians at election time. The same is true in India. In other countries, including Nigeria, Philippines, and Colombia the precarious working conditions of news staff provide fertile conditions for corruption and “brown envelopes” or under-the-table cash payments to reporters and editors which are a routine feature of journalistic work. The struggles facing journalists in settled democracies, such as the United Kingdom and Denmark, are less brazen, but no less challenging and in a range of countries across the Western Balkans with a shared and painful history, media corruption hinders aspirations to break free from the legacy of war, censorship and political control during decades of communist rule. The story is of an uphill struggle. Everywhere there is a crisis of confidence inside newsrooms caused by crumbling levels of commitment to ethics, a lowering of the status of journalistic work and a pervasive lack of transparency over advertising, ownership and corporate and political affiliations. Government control over lucrative state advertising, which is often allocated to media according to their political bias, remains widespread. At the same time, the elimination in most countries of the invisible wall separating editorial and advertising has created a surge of so-called “native advertising,” hidden advertorials and paid-for journalism. It was this conflict of interest that plunged the crisis-prone UK press into a new bout of handwringing in February 2015 when Peter Oborne, a leading political journalist, quit his job at the Daily Telegraph accusing the management of censoring stories about HSBC bank, a leading advertiser caught up in a tax scandal. These reports tell essentially the same story of deep cuts in editorial investment, undue pressure on newsrooms, and media increasingly dependent upon atypical models of ownership in which media have become the trophy possessions of powerful figures and institutions in pursuit of wider corporate and political objectives." (Introduction, page iii-iv)
Western Balkans: Corruption in media slows progress to democracy / Sanela Hodžic, 1
Colombia: Corruption, censorship and bullet points for ethical journalism / Jonathan Bock, 9
Denmark: Media transparency is the key in a world of challenges / Suzanne Mol, 15
Egypt: Zig-zag politics and the scourge of paid for journalism / Tarek Atia and Mohamed Abdel-Rahman, 21
India: Boom-time for media but with a growing ethical deficit / A.S. Panneerselvan, 27
Malaysia: State power, bribery and internet pollution of journalism / Steven Gan, 33
Mexico: Journalism in the crosshairs of politics and corruption / Elva Narcia, 41
Nigeria: Calls for ethical revival as corruption infects media / Lanre Arogundade, 49
Philippines: How media corruption nourishes old systems of bias and control / Melinda Quintos de Jesus, 57
Turkey: Journalism a victim of cosy relations between politics and media / Ceren Sözeri, 63
United Kingdom: The self-inflicted wounds that point to enemies within media / Rich Peppiat, 69
Ukraine: Paid journalism - fooling the people for political favours / Lesia Ganzha and Oleksii Pogorelov, 75