Uncovering news deserts in Europe: Risks and opportunities for local and community media in the EU
Deep Insights
San Domenico di Fiesole (Italy): European University Institute (2024), 224 pp.
ISBN 978-92-9466-543-0
"This research is focused on detecting challenges and opportunities for local and community media and identifying news deserts in the 27 EU Member States. It entails a holistic approach towards the concept of news desert, interpreting it as an area that is lacking sufficient, reliable and diverse information from trustworthy media sources. The risk for local and community media has been assessed through several indicators which are related to the number of media outlets, economic and political conditions, as well as degree of safety of local journalists and the social inclusiveness of local and community media towards minorities, marginalised communities and the capability of engaging with the audience. This investigation also identified examples of best innovative practices in the local and community media sector that could be deemed beneficial for a vibrant and open public sphere. The study’s holistic approach considers the complexities and specificities of local media markets in each EU Member State. In some countries, the issues and challenges for local media are widespread across the entire country – while in others, these challenges are limited to specific regions or even cities – leaving certain communities without access to local media that disseminate public interest information. This assessment is not fixed in time and requires continuous monitoring. Looking at the existence of local media and local journalists on the ground, the situation for news services in rural areas is increasingly problematic, due to both issues related to distribution and a decreasing number of points of sale, as well as to the digital shift coupled with an ageing rural population. Furthermore, newsrooms and journalists are increasingly centralised in the main regional cities, reaching the most remote areas only occasionally or conducting desk journalism exclusively. Public service media, often entrusted with covering the entire national territory, has proven to be crucial in guaranteeing an adequate coverage of regional and local areas, both geographically, and in terms of offering services in minority languages." (Executive summary, page 1)
"The questionnaire consists of 55 questions (variables) of legal, economic and socio-political nature, clustered into 6 indicators. It is built in a way that allows for the gathering of both quantitative and qualitative data, and for cross-comparative analyses between EU member states. The data gathered with the questionnaire have been reviewed by the CMPF researchers and finally compiled in this final report, divided into country sections, by the respective authors. The questionnaire is composed of 12 contextual variables, considered as independent variables for the purpose of this research. They cover general questions about the country size, population, general state of play in the local and community media sector. No risk score is associated with these questions. Following the above-mentioned section, the questionnaire is composed of 6 indicators aimed at evaluating the risks for local and community media, in the countries under study. These indicators are: granularity of the infrastructure of local media [...], market and reach [...], safety of local journalists [...], editorial independence [...], social inclusiveness [...], best practices and open public sphere [...]" (Methodology, pages 6-7)
Methodology, 6
Austria / Maren Beaufort, Andreas Schulz-Tomancok, 8
Belgium / Olivier Standaert, 14
Bulgaria / Orlin Spassov, Nelly Ognyanova, Nikoleta Daskalova, 22
Croatia / Dina Vozab, Antonija Čuvalo, 29
Cyprus / Nicholas Karides, Christophoros Christophorou, 36
Czech Republic / Lucie Sýkorová, Lenka Waschková Císařová, 41
Denmark / Sandra Simonsen, 48
Estonia / Signe Ivask, 55
Finland / Carl-Gustav Lindén, Mikko Grönlund, 63
France / Franck Bousquet, 69
Germany / Jan Christopher Kalbhenn, 76
Greece / Lambrini Papadopoulou, Ioannis Angelou, 82
Hungary / Gábor Polyák, Ágnes Urbán, 89
Ireland / Eileen Culloty, 97
Italy / Andrea Mangani, 104
Latvia / Anda Rožukalne, Jānis Juzefovičs, 112
Lithuania / Auksė Balčytienė, Deimantas Jastramskis, 119
Luxembourg / Stephanie Lukasik, 126
Malta / Louiselle Vassallo, 133
Poland / Katarzyna Vanevska, 140
Portugal / Dora Santos-Silva, Carla Baptista, Luís Bonixe, Luís Oliveira Martins, Patrícia Caneira, 147
Romania / Raluca Toma, Roxana Bodea, 154
Slovakia / Marína Urbániková, 162
Slovenia / Romana Biljak Gerjevič, 168
Spain / Elena Yeste Piquer, 175
Sweden / Elisabeth Stur, Asta Cepaite Nilsson, 183
The Netherlands / Yael de Haan, 190
Comparative analysis, conclusions and recommendations, 197
Austria / Maren Beaufort, Andreas Schulz-Tomancok, 8
Belgium / Olivier Standaert, 14
Bulgaria / Orlin Spassov, Nelly Ognyanova, Nikoleta Daskalova, 22
Croatia / Dina Vozab, Antonija Čuvalo, 29
Cyprus / Nicholas Karides, Christophoros Christophorou, 36
Czech Republic / Lucie Sýkorová, Lenka Waschková Císařová, 41
Denmark / Sandra Simonsen, 48
Estonia / Signe Ivask, 55
Finland / Carl-Gustav Lindén, Mikko Grönlund, 63
France / Franck Bousquet, 69
Germany / Jan Christopher Kalbhenn, 76
Greece / Lambrini Papadopoulou, Ioannis Angelou, 82
Hungary / Gábor Polyák, Ágnes Urbán, 89
Ireland / Eileen Culloty, 97
Italy / Andrea Mangani, 104
Latvia / Anda Rožukalne, Jānis Juzefovičs, 112
Lithuania / Auksė Balčytienė, Deimantas Jastramskis, 119
Luxembourg / Stephanie Lukasik, 126
Malta / Louiselle Vassallo, 133
Poland / Katarzyna Vanevska, 140
Portugal / Dora Santos-Silva, Carla Baptista, Luís Bonixe, Luís Oliveira Martins, Patrícia Caneira, 147
Romania / Raluca Toma, Roxana Bodea, 154
Slovakia / Marína Urbániková, 162
Slovenia / Romana Biljak Gerjevič, 168
Spain / Elena Yeste Piquer, 175
Sweden / Elisabeth Stur, Asta Cepaite Nilsson, 183
The Netherlands / Yael de Haan, 190
Comparative analysis, conclusions and recommendations, 197